Are Your Hands Too Small?
I often meet people who are concerned that their hands are too small to play alto, tenor, or bass recorders.
Maybe they’ve tried to produce a low note on an alto or a tenor and haven’t had success. Or perhaps they’re struggling to hold the instrument in a comfortable way. In cases like this, many people wonder: Are my hands simply too small?
As with most questions, the answer is….maybe!
But also, maybe not. There are definitely adults out there with hands that are too small to play conventional tenors. And there are even adults out there with hands too small to play alto. But in my experience, when given the right approach and technique, the first group becomes much smaller than you’d think. And the second group, while extant, is miniscule.
Your hands may not be big, but with patience, experimentation, and technical know-how, it’s more than possible that your hands are big enough.
So how the heck do you tell if your difficulties are physiological, technical, or somewhere in between? It’s not an exact science, but here are some questions to ask yourself:
What’s your hand span? In my experience, if you can play an octave on the piano, you’ll most likely be able to conquer the alto. And if you can play a ninth (my own span) or greater, you can almost always master bass and tenor (Fun fact: the hand spread on the bass is often less than the spread on a tenor!). I like sharing this information with students because often merely knowing that something can be achieved does a lot of the work of getting you there.
Do you have arthritis? Arthritis of the hands can definitely complicate things. But don’t write yourself off up front: manifestations vary widely. I have many students with arthritis who play all sizes of instrument. Experiment and use your personal judgment.
Have you given it time? One of the biggest mistakes I see learners make is to assume that if they can’t access a low note consistently the first few times out, or within the first few weeks or even months, their hands are too small and they’ll never be able to. But low notes are quite difficult on the recorder, and even students with very large hands struggle. Yes, you may have small hands and issues with low notes, but correlation does not imply causation; it may just be that you’re still learning what you need to do technically to produce low notes. Or your hands may simply need time to accustom themselves to a more substantial stretch.
Have you examined your technique? Low notes can be a struggle for a wide variety of reasons entirely unrelated to hand size (e.g., finger coverage, angle of play, how you’re supporting the instrument’s weight, air volume, air speed, mouth position, tongue movement). That’s one reason I really like the hand span metric….if your hands are of suitable size and you’re still struggling, it’s fairly likely that your technique is the culprit.
Can you modify how you play?
If you are struggling with a larger instrument, there are lots of technical shifts you can try before giving up. Can you support the weight of the instrument in a different way (e.g., thumbrest, neck strap, crossbar support)? Can you reposition your right thumb? Can you shift the vertical angle of the instrument? Can you shift the horizontal angle of the instrument (typically this means moving the end of the instrument toward the right)? Can you relax your right hand when not playing?
Can you modify the instrument?
If your hands are, in fact, too small to play a conventional tenor, all hope is not lost! Often, it’s as simple as trying a different model of instrument. First, you could try a conventional tenor that’s on the smaller side (e.g., the Aulos Robin). If that’s still too big, try a tenor with adaptive keywork or even a bent neck (e.g., Mollenauer’s Comfort Tenor). The new Sigo tenor by Kunath may also be an option.
Do you have to play larger sizes of instrument? Of course not. But in my view missing out on tenor should be something you choose, not something you feel forced into by your anatomy!